Community Velocity Model Technical Activity Group Workshop
Applications Due: August 15, 2019 |
Convener: Cliff Thurber
WORKSHOP SUMMARY: A SCEC workshop was held in October 2018 on future development of SCEC Community Velocity Models (CVMs). The goals of that workshop were as follows: (1) assess the current status of the CVMs for California; (2) define key information needed to improve and/or develop CVMs; (3) propose viable workflow strategies for CVM development; (4) identify approaches for assessing CVM uncertainties. An essential next step is the formation of a Technical Activity Group (TAG) tasked with further developing and collectively carrying out a coordinated set of activities to improve and validate the CVMs. The mission of this Technical Activity Group (TAG) is to promote and coordinate efforts to improve SCEC Community Velocity Models (CVMs). This TAG will help galvanize efforts to develop and apply an open framework for the assessment, validation, and improvement of CVMs. This full-day workshop, to be held in conjunction with the September 2019 SCEC Annual Meeting, will be the first meeting of the CVM TAG.
WORKSHOP GOALS: A substantial effort has gone into the development of the two "standard" SCEC CVMs for Southern California, currently CVM-H version 15.1.0 (Shaw et al., 2015) and CVM-S version 4.26 (Lee et al., 2014). Incremental improvements are being made to CVM-H over time, but CVM-S model is essentially frozen at the current version. SCEC has also developed a Central California Area CVM, current version CCA-06. SCEC's Unified CVM framework (Small et al., 2017) provides access to these models as well as other models covering different regions of California, including the San Francisco Bay Area and the entire state. To make further progress on these CVMs, open-source workflows are needed to evaluate and/or update these models, methods need to be developed to merge new high-resolution localized models into the existing models, strategies to integrate constraints from other geophysical, geotechnical, and geological sources are required, and methods for assessing model uncertainty must be developed. This TAG will facilitate research initiatives at the intersection of seismology, ground motion, and computational science.
The proposed goals for the CVM TAG are:
- Develop open methods for improving SCEC CVMs;
- Develop methods for CVM assessment and validation, including providing uncertainty estimates;
- Expand the participation of SCEC researchers in work related to improving and utilizing the CVMs.
The tasks for the workshop are (1) to reach final consensus on the mission and goals statement of the TAG (a draft of which will be circulated in advance of the workshop), (2) to refine and prioritize the identified action items, and (3) to coordinate plans for submission of related SCEC 2020 proposals as well as future proposals to other funding agencies. The primary outcomes expected from the workshop are a completed mission and goals statement for the CVM TAG, including prioritized action items, and plans for submission of coordinated and collaborative proposals in response to the 2020 SCEC Science Collaboration Plan and other funding opportunities.
To promote discussion and due to logistics, the workshop is limited to 30 participants. Interested participants should contact the workshop convener to inquire about space availability.
Presentation slides may be downloaded by clicking the links following the title. PLEASE NOTE: Files are the author’s property. They may contain unpublished or preliminary information and should only be used while viewing the talk.
SATURDAY, SEPTEMBER 7, 2019
08:30 - 09:00 | Workshop Check-In | |
Session 1: Overview, Desired Outcomes, Motivation, and Framework Moderators: Cliff Thurber and Elizabeth Berg |
||
09:00 - 09:20 | Welcome and Overview of Workshop Objectives (PDF, 550KB) | Cliff Thurber |
09:20 - 09:40 | Perspective on SCEC’s CVM needs | Yehuda Ben-Zion |
09:40 - 10:00 | CVMs and the UCVM (PDF, 3.3MB) | Phil Maechling |
10:00 - 10:30 | Discussion | All |
10:30 - 10:40 | Break | |
Session 2: Improving SCEC CVMs Moderators: Amir Allam and Alan Juarez |
||
10:40 - 11:00 | Efforts to improve CVM-H (PDF, 3.2MB) | Andreas Plesch |
11:00 - 11:20 | Developing an open-source FWT workflow (PDF, 10.2MB) | Carl Tape |
11:20 - 11:40 | Discussion | All |
11:40 - 12:40 | Lunch | |
Session 2: CVM assessment and validation Moderators: Carl Tape and Chengping Chai |
||
12:40 - 13:00 | Assessment of Community Velocity Models through the lens of Ground Motion Simulation Validation (PDF, 4.7MB) | Ricardo Taborda |
13:00 - 13:20 | Example of CVM assessment and validation II | Artie Rogers |
13:20 - 13:40 | Assessment of CVM-S5 Including A Statistical Model of Small-scale Heterogeneities (PDF, 3.7MB) | Kim Olsen |
13:40 - 14:00 | Discussion | All |
Session 3: New Techniques and Related Efforts Moderator: Phil Maechling |
||
14:00 - 14:20 | New imaging techniques (PDF, 19.8MB) | Rob Clayton |
14:20 - 14:40 | Imaging earth structure with machine learning (PDF, 4.6MB) | Michael Bianco |
14:40 - 15:00 | San Francisco Bay Area 3D geologic and seismic velocity models | Brad Aagaard |
15:00 - 15:20 | New Zealand CVMs (PDF, 3.3MB) | Brendon Bradley |
15:20 - 15:40 | Discussion | All |
15:40 - 16:00 | Break | |
Session 4: Action Item Prioritization and Funding Opportunities Moderators: Cliff Thurber and Lise Retailleau |
||
16:00 - 16:10 | Action items recap (PDF, 84KB) | Cliff Thurber |
16:10 - 16:30 | Funding opportunities within and outside SCEC | Yehuda Ben-Zion |
16:30 - 17:00 | Discussion: Workshop recommendations and future plans | All |
17:00 | Workshop Adjourns |
It is SCEC policy to foster harassment-free environments wherever our science is conducted. By accepting an invitation to participate in a SCEC-supported event, by email or online registration, participants agree to abide by the SCEC Activities Code of Conduct.
PARTICIPANTS
Amir Allam (U Utah)
Yehuda Ben-Zion (SCEC/USC)
Elizabeth Berg (U Utah)
Greg Beroza (Stanford)
Michael Bianco (Scripps/UCSD)
Brianna Birkel (USC)
Brendon Bradley (U Canterbury)
Scott Callaghan (SCEC/USC)
Chengping Chai (ORNL)
Robert Clayton (Caltech)
William Eymold (Ohio State)
Christine Goulet (SCEC/USC)
Liz Hearn (Capstone Geophysics)
Evan Hirakawa (USGS)
Aaron Hirsch (U Rhode Island)
Tom Jordan (USC)
Alan Juarez (USC)
Kazuki Koketsu (ERI Tokyo)
Anna Kowal (U Otago)
Robin Lee (U Canterbury)
Phil Maechling (SCEC/USC)
Xiaofeng Meng (SCEC/USC)
Sarah Neill (U Canterbury)
Trung Dung Nguyen (Canterbury, NZ)
Chukwuebuka Nweke (UCLA)
Ossian O'Reilly (SCEC/USC)
Kim Olsen (SDSU)
Sunyoung Park (Caltech)
Arben Pitarka (LLNL)
Andreas Plesch (Harvard)
Hongrui Qiu (Rice)
Lise Retailleau (Stanford)
Artie Rodgers (LLNL)
Valerie Sahakian (U Oregon)
John Shaw (Harvard)
Ricardo Taborda (EAFIT)
Taka'aki Taira (UC-Berkeley)
Carl Tape (Univ of Alaska)
Cliff Thurber (UW-Madison)
John Vidale (USC)
This workshop is held prior to the 2019 SCEC Annual Meeting.